What are the key things you need to know about redundancy?


I recently read the case of Hodgson v Amcor Ltd; Amcor Ltd & Ors v Barnes & Ors [2012] VSC 94 which addressed a number of key principles of redundancy.

Hodgson had been employed by Amcor Ltd for 38 years and was made redundant by the company at age 61. His annual remuneration package was as follows:

  • Base salary;
  • Superannuation;
  • Housing allowance;
  • Motor vehicle allowance;
  • Total remuneration sum of $750,000.00.

No period of notice in the event of redundancy was specified in Hodgson’s employment contract; however, Amcor Ltd had a company Redundancy Policy which applied to all employees.

Amcor’s Redundancy Policy

The Redundancy policy expressly applied to senior management and all staff members.

It stated that all redundant employees were entitled to be paid three weeks base salary for each completed year of continuous service. The maximum under the redundancy policy was 52 weeks pay.

The Supreme Court held that this policy formed part of Hodgson’s employment contract.


The Supreme Court of Victoria ruled that Hodgson had not been made genuinely redundant because the restructure of the company did not cause his role to be modified sufficiently enough to fundamentally change the nature of his position. Further, there was an insufficient redistribution of Hodgson’s job functions.

Accordingly, Amcor was order to pay a total of $917,695.00 to Hodgson which included payment in lieu of notice, accrued annual leave and long service leave. The order also included a bonus payment of $160,000.00 which Hodgson would have receive had his employment not been terminated.

Key Findings

The Supreme Court of Victoria drew some key findings about redundancy in this case which should be kept in mind:

  1. A job becomes redundant only when the employer no longer requires to have the job performed by anyone; (or)
  2. For all practical purposes the duties of the job have changed so in effect the original role no longer exists; (or)
  3. The Employer is required to redistribute the duties of the job among other employees which means that in effect the original role ceases to exist.

It is very important when considering terminating an employee, that you carefully consider your legal position. It is usually important to consider these issues when preparing employee agreements.

Please contact me if you have any questions in regards to redundancy and employment agreements.

Tagged in: , , , , , , ,

You may also be interested in:

6 Things You Can Expect When Declaring Bankruptcy

Declaring bankruptcy should be your last resort when you are faced with financial difficulties, whether as an individual or as a business owner. It is not exactly a “Get Out of Jail Free” card, as it comes with many adverse consequences, which may significantly impact your financial standing over a considerable period. So what consequences continue reading

How do you determine if a company is insolvent?

The answer to the question “How do you determine if a company is insolvent?” is important because there are serious consequences for a director if debts are incurred after the company has become insolvent, including civil penalties, compensation proceedings and criminal charges. However, it is often difficult to know when a company has crossed the continue reading

What to do if you receive an ATO Director Penalty Notice

Did you know that company directors may potentially become personally liable for unremitted Pay As You Go (PAYG) deductions and Superannuation Guarantee Charges (SGCs)? The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has significant powers to recover a company’s unpaid liabilities personally through its directors and may issue a Director Penalty Notice (DPN). This article focuses on the continue reading

Liability Limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation | Website by VA